Daxonétété William
In recent years, many African nations have embarked on the journey of modernizing their identification systems through biometric technology. This involves advanced methods like fingerprint scans, facial recognition, and iris scans, which hold the promise of streamlining citizen verification processes. For governments, the allure of biometric ID systems lies in their potential to combat fraud, enhance service delivery, and improve governance. However, the reality on the ground has proven to be far more complex. Numerous biometric ID projects across the continent have either faced significant delays or failed altogether. The latest cautionary tale comes from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), where a $1.2 billion biometric ID project was abruptly cancelled, leaving the country grappling with the reasons for its failure.
The DRC’s biometric ID project was, at first, heralded as a transformational initiative. It was envisioned as a solution that would provide millions of Congolese citizens with a secure, modern means of identification. Initially estimated to cost $360 million, the project was soon mired in controversy as costs skyrocketed to $1.2 billion. The contract was awarded to French firm Idemia, in collaboration with Afritech, but suspicions arose when financial discrepancies were uncovered by a joint investigation from Bloomberg and Lighthouse. The process was shrouded in opacity, with accusations of irregularities in the bidding process. Even the World Bank, a potential funder, withdrew its support due to concerns about the project’s transparency. In August 2024, the government officially cancelled the project, leaving citizens frustrated and without the promised identification system.
This failure in the DRC echoes a broader pattern seen across several African nations. Nigeria, Kenya, and others have faced their own challenges with biometric ID systems, raising the question: why do so many of these projects struggle in Africa? One of the fundamental issues lies in the continent’s underdeveloped infrastructure. Rolling out biometric systems requires a stable foundation, including consistent access to electricity, internet, and secure data storage facilities—resources that are often in short supply, particularly in rural areas. Without this infrastructure, the sophisticated technology behind biometric IDs cannot function effectively, leading to system breakdowns and delays.
Beyond infrastructure, corruption and financial mismanagement have played a major role in derailing these projects. The DRC’s ballooning costs, for instance, are a clear indication of poor financial oversight. Projects that begin with reasonable budgets can quickly spiral out of control due to corrupt practices, lack of accountability, and poorly negotiated contracts. When contracts are awarded without a transparent and competitive process, the result is often inflated costs and substandard delivery of services, which ultimately contribute to the project’s failure.
Another key challenge is the heavy reliance on foreign companies to develop and implement these systems. While foreign expertise can be valuable, it also comes at a steep price, as seen in the DRC’s partnership with the French firm Idemia. Many African governments outsource their biometric projects to foreign companies, often paying premium rates for solutions that may not be fully adapted to local conditions. Moreover, when issues arise, these foreign contractors may not have the deep-rooted accountability needed to address them effectively, leaving governments to deal with the fallout.
Cost overruns have also been a persistent problem in many biometric ID projects. The complex technology, combined with the need for skilled personnel and extensive infrastructure, often leads to budget estimates that fall short of the true costs. In the DRC, what was initially seen as a $360 million project quickly swelled to more than triple that amount, straining the country’s financial resources. This pattern of unexpected cost escalations has been a recurring theme in other African countries, creating significant financial burdens.
Political instability further complicates the rollout of such large-scale projects. In countries like the DRC, where governance is often in flux, long-term initiatives like biometric ID systems can be derailed by shifting political priorities or crises. When governments change or face internal conflicts, projects that require sustained focus and investment can be sidelined, leaving them incomplete or abandoned altogether. The DRC’s political instability over the years has undoubtedly contributed to the failure of its biometric project.
Compounding these technical and political challenges is a deep-seated public distrust of biometric systems. In many African countries, citizens are wary of how their personal data will be collected, stored, and used. Without clear communication from governments about data protection and privacy measures, people are often hesitant to participate in these initiatives. This lack of trust can lead to resistance, slowing down or even halting the implementation of biometric systems, as governments struggle to gain public buy-in.
Despite these challenges, the failure of the DRC’s biometric ID project offers valuable lessons for the future. One of the most important takeaways is the need for transparency. Governments must prioritize openness in the bidding process, financial management, and project execution. By ensuring transparency, they can reduce the risk of corruption and mismanagement, while building trust with both the public and international partners.
Additionally, African countries should invest in developing local technology ecosystems that can support the implementation of these systems. Relying on foreign companies has its pitfalls, as seen in the DRC’s experience. By fostering local talent and businesses, governments can reduce costs and ensure that projects are more responsive to local needs and conditions. Starting small and scaling up gradually, rather than launching massive nationwide initiatives all at once, can also help manage costs and ensure that the systems are functioning effectively before they are rolled out on a larger scale.
Moreover, public education campaigns are crucial to building trust in biometric systems. Governments need to explain not just how these systems work, but why they are necessary and how citizens’ data will be protected. When people understand the benefits and feel assured about their privacy, they are more likely to support such initiatives. Lastly, international oversight and adherence to global data protection standards can provide additional layers of accountability, ensuring that biometric ID projects are executed with integrity.
While the DRC’s biometric ID project is a stark reminder of the challenges facing such initiatives in Africa, it should not mark the end of efforts to modernize identification systems on the continent. The need for secure and reliable identification is still urgent, and biometric technology remains a promising solution. By learning from past failures, improving governance, and building trust, African countries can overcome the hurdles and implement systems that truly benefit their citizens.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings